Witchy Fingers

Witchy Fingers

Get your Halloween on with these Witchy Finger cookies. So much fun to make with your kids!


2 ¼ cup Flour

½ cup Crisco

1 Stick Butter

Cream the above ingredients together in a bowl.



¾ cup Powdered Sugar

1 Egg

10 Drops Green Food Color

Pinch of salt

Mix and refrigerate for a ½ hour

Roll pieces of dough out about 2 inches, the approximate size of your finger.  Put two dents right below and above where your knuckle would be.

Put 3 lines on your knuckle and one right behind where the fingernail would be.

Put almond on point side out for fingernail.

Refrigerate for 20 minutes.

Bake 10-12 minutes at 350 degreesYou can put melted chocolate around the nail, will help hold it in place and also dip in Strawberry jam, or buy Sweet Cherry Chips for the blood affect.  They are hard to find, Econo Foods has them.

Keep Smiling!!!!


Back to blog